B12 Magazine

Daily from the four markets B12 Group works in

Car Trading

Used luxury car values slip as EV prices firm in the US

Mid-November wholesale data show used luxury car values down 3.5 per cent on a year earlier while used electric vehicles gained, reshaping the resale arithmetic for buyers.

NewsB12 Group10 min read

Used luxury car values in the United States are moving in the opposite direction to the wider market. Wholesale data for the first half of November 2026, compiled by Cox Automotive from its Manheim auctions, show luxury vehicles 3.5 per cent cheaper than a year earlier, while used electric vehicles were 3.4 per cent dearer and compact cars rose 10 per cent. For anyone thinking about depreciation, resale value or the right moment to buy or sell a premium car, the split is worth understanding.

The American wholesale market is one of the most closely tracked used-car markets in the world, and its signals tend to travel. When dealers there pay less for three-year-old luxury saloons and SUVs, the effect is felt in trade-in offers, lease pricing and, eventually, in what buyers elsewhere expect to pay for similar cars. The November numbers describe a market that is broadly stable on the surface, but shifting underneath.

The headline: a flat index with a seasonal dip

The Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index, the industry's main measure of wholesale used-vehicle prices adjusted for mix, mileage and season, stood at 206.8 in the first 15 days of November. CBT News reported that this was unchanged from the October close and 0.7 per cent higher than in November 2025, a narrower annual gain than the 2 per cent recorded in October. The index had reached 207.4 in mid-October before easing.

Before seasonal adjustment, wholesale prices fell 0.7 per cent over the same fortnight. Cox Automotive described the decline as seasonal, and Custer Consulting Group, which tracks the data, noted that the long-term average movement for the whole of November is a fall of 0.4 per cent. This year's first-half drop was steeper than in the previous two years. In the phrasing relayed by Custer Consulting, Cox characterised the market as one where “sellers are meeting the market on price rather than buyers chasing inventory.”

The official full-month reading for November is due on 7 December, according to Custer Consulting. Mid-month figures are an early indication rather than a final verdict, but the direction of travel is clear enough to be useful.

Activity, at least, has held up. CBT News reported that the number of cars sold through the Manheim auctions was roughly 6 per cent higher than a year earlier through mid-month, and that the sales conversion rate, the share of cars offered that actually sold, averaged 56.8 per cent in the first half of November, up 4.6 points on a year earlier and 3.1 points on October. Wholesale supply stood at 27.9 days on 15 November, down from 28.4 days at the end of October and below last year's level. Cars are changing hands briskly; they are simply doing so at prices that reflect what buyers are prepared to pay.

Luxury values fall 3.5 per cent year on year

The segment breakdown is where the story lies. Custer Consulting's summary of the Cox data shows the following year-on-year movements for the first half of November: compact cars up 10.0 per cent, midsize cars up 1.3 per cent, SUVs and crossovers down 1.0 per cent, pickups down 0.7 per cent, and luxury vehicles down 3.5 per cent, the weakest of the major segments. CBT News confirmed that luxury, SUVs and pickups were all below last year's levels, with compact cars leading the gains.

Several forces help explain the pattern. Cox's third-quarter report, published on 7 October, noted that older and more affordable vehicles had depreciated less than the market because demand for them remained relatively strong. Large pickups and SUVs, by contrast, absorbed more of the impact of higher fuel costs. CBT News reported that petrol prices are running about 90 cents a gallon above a year earlier, while the 10-year US Treasury yield has climbed back above 5 per cent and markets are pricing a high probability of an interest-rate rise by the Federal Reserve in December.

Luxury cars are exposed to both pressures. They tend to be larger and thirstier than mainstream models, and they are more often bought with finance or leased, which makes their buyers sensitive to borrowing costs. When monthly payments rise and running costs climb, buyers trade down, and the wholesale value of expensive used cars is the first place it shows.

Faster depreciation for three-year-old cars

Depreciation itself has picked up. CBT News reported that the Cox index tracking three-year-old vehicles fell 0.9 per cent from the start of November, and that depreciation is running faster than normal. Custer Consulting described overall depreciation in the first half of the month as slightly above the long-term average, though the three-year-old decline was marginally smaller than at the same point last year.

The third quarter was already a turning point. Cox's 7 October release reported that the September index stood at 205.9, down 0.6 per cent from a year earlier and 1.1 per cent from August, and that depreciation accelerated during the quarter after stronger-than-normal appreciation in the first half of 2026. Cox's chief economist, Jeremy Robb, described the period as the weakest season for wholesale valuations and pointed to the conflict in the Middle East, record diesel prices and rapidly rising interest rates as reasons for caution heading into the fourth quarter.

In response, Cox lowered its year-end forecast. It now expects the Manheim index to finish 2026 about 0.2 per cent higher than a year earlier, down from the 2 per cent gain it had forecast in July. For context, the index rose 0.4 per cent in 2025, and its long-term average annual increase is 2.3 per cent.

Volumes overall remain healthy. In its October release, Cox raised its forecast for total US used-vehicle sales in 2026 to 38.5 million, with retail used sales of 20.5 million, while it expects certified pre-owned sales, the manufacturer-backed segment that matters most for luxury brands, to be unchanged at 2.6 million, 1.8 per cent lower than a year earlier. Demand for used cars has not disappeared; it has become more selective about price.

Used EV prices: wholesale up, retail softer

Electric vehicles are the exception. In the first half of November, Cox's EV index was 3.4 per cent higher than a year earlier, according to CBT News, although it slipped 0.7 per cent from October and the annual gain had been 6.6 per cent in October. Custer Consulting put the EV index at 199.9, against a base of 100 in January 2015, while non-electric vehicles were down 0.1 per cent year on year.

Demand is the driver. Cox's October EV Market Monitor, reported by CBT News on 17 November, estimated that 48,678 used EVs were sold in the US in October, up 73.2 per cent on a year earlier and 4.7 per cent on September. Used EVs accounted for 3.3 per cent of all used-vehicle sales, up from 2 per cent a year before. The days' supply of used EVs, a measure of how long current stock would last at the current selling rate, stood at 38 days, 18.8 per cent lower than a year earlier and well below the 47 days for petrol and other non-electric cars.

Yet the retail picture is more nuanced. The same report put the average listing price of a used EV at $36,582, down 0.5 per cent from September and 1.9 per cent from a year earlier. Used EVs carried an average premium of $2,236, or 6.5 per cent, over comparable combustion-engined vehicles. In other words, dealers are paying more at wholesale for the EVs they can sell quickly, but the asking prices consumers see have not risen in step.

More EVs are coming off lease

Supply is the factor to watch. Cox's third-quarter report noted that wholesale EV sales rose 22 per cent from the second quarter and 45 per cent from a year earlier, and that EVs reached a record 4.9 per cent of Manheim transactions, up from 3.9 per cent. Used retail EV sales hit a record of about 124,000 units in the quarter, up 11.4 per cent year on year.

Much of that supply comes from cars returning at the end of leases. Cox estimates that EVs made up about 10 per cent of off-lease supply in the first half of 2026, a share it expects to rise to about 16 per cent in the second half and about 19 per cent by the summer of 2027. Total off-lease supply is rising too, from about 190,000 to about 220,000 units a month between the first and second halves of this year.

So far, buyers have absorbed the extra cars. Whether they continue to do so as the flow increases will decide whether today's firm EV values hold, or whether used EV prices come under renewed pressure in 2027.

Premium brands inside the EV market

The luxury brands are visible within these numbers. CBT News reported that BMW ranked fifth among brands for used EV sales in October, behind Tesla, Chevrolet, Ford and Hyundai. The days' supply of used Mercedes-Benz EVs fell by 16 days to 47, a sign of quicker turnover, while Audi's used EV supply rose by six days to 47.

On the new-car side, the October report estimated 83,262 new EV sales, up 3 per cent year on year and the first annual increase of 2026, in what CBT News described as the first comparison against a month without the federal EV tax credit. The average transaction price of a new EV was $56,220, with incentives averaging $6,375 per vehicle, or 11.3 per cent of the price, up from 10.3 per cent a year earlier. Generous discounts on new cars inevitably weigh on what nearly new used examples are worth.

What it means for buying and selling a luxury car

For buyers and sellers of premium cars, three practical points follow from the data.

For buyers, softer luxury values are an opportunity. A three-year-old luxury saloon or SUV bought today should cost less than the same car a year ago, and with depreciation running faster than usual, there may be more room to negotiate. The caution is that falling values affect the buyer too when it is time to sell, so the condition, specification and history of the individual car matter more, not less.

For sellers, timing and presentation count. In a market where sellers are adjusting to the price buyers will pay, a car with complete service records, original accessories and no unexplained gaps in its history is the one most likely to achieve a strong price. A car that needs explaining will be priced accordingly.

For anyone weighing an electric luxury car, the resale picture is better than many assume, at least for now. Wholesale EV values are rising and demand for used EVs is growing quickly. But the wave of off-lease EVs that Cox expects through 2027 means the balance between supply and demand could shift, and large incentives on new EVs continue to set a ceiling for nearly new prices.

Beyond the American market

The figures in this article describe the United States, and other markets have their own dynamics, from local fuel prices and financing costs to import rules and buyer preferences. In the Gulf, where large luxury SUVs and high-performance cars are a familiar part of the market, buyers should treat American data as a signal of global sentiment rather than a direct price guide. The underlying lesson travels well, though: when the wider market softens, documented, well-kept cars hold their value best.

The B12 view

The November data describe a used-car market that looks calm at headline level but is redistributing value underneath: away from large, expensive luxury vehicles exposed to fuel and finance costs, and towards affordable cars and, for now, electric ones. For buyers, that creates openings; for sellers, it raises the premium on preparation. The constant is that the car itself, its condition, history and specification, decides its price. That is why B12 Auto Trading inspects every car in its showroom before it is offered, and why a careful inspection remains the most valuable step in any purchase, whichever way the market is moving.

More from Car Trading

Call us free